Don’t hit me over the head, but I am about to state the obvious: It looks like real estate investors are not buying right now, and for good reason. The market is frozen in a way that we haven’t seen in decades, and the factors driving this stagnation are piling up. Let’s break down exactly why capital is sitting on the sidelines, when that might change, and what this means for the future of real estate investment.
1. High Interest Rates Are Killing Deals
The Federal Reserve’s aggressive rate hikes have pushed mortgage rates to 7-8%, making financing too expensive for most deals to pencil out. With the 30-day SOFR currently at 4.35% (fred.stlouisfed.org), borrowing costs remain significantly higher than in previous years. This increase has eroded cash flow and made cap rates unattractive relative to alternative investments like private credit and T-bills, where investors can find higher yields with lower risk. Even as mortgage rates have dipped slightly to around 6.6%, the cost of capital is still limiting new acquisitions, keeping many investors on the sidelines.
2. Sellers Refuse to Adjust Pricing
The market is stuck in a standoff—sellers are holding onto pre-2022 valuations, while buyers are expecting significant discounts. Many owners locked in record-low interest rates and aren’t in a rush to sell unless forced to, which means price discovery is completely frozen. jpmorgan.com
3. Distress Is Coming—But It’s Not Here Yet
Investors are awaiting forced sales and distressed assets to enter the market. However, lenders are employing “extend and pretend” strategies, modifying loans to delay defaults. This tactic has led to a surge in loan modifications, with 2,778 loans totaling $35.5 billion adjusted over the past three years. Until these underlying issues become more pronounced, investors remain hesitant to re-enter the market.globest.com
4. Alternative Investments Look More Attractive
Why buy an overleveraged property when private credit, corporate bonds, and T-bills are offering higher yields with significantly less risk? With the 30-day SOFR at 4.35% (fred.stlouisfed.org), and Treasury bills yielding over 5%, many investors see little reason to take on illiquid real estate equity risk when they can earn stable nominal returns elsewhere.
This leaves a major gap to be filled in the equity slot—someone still has to step up and take on development risk, lease-up risk, and cap rate compression risk. But right now, family offices and institutions are choosing safety, shifting capital away from traditional CRE equity and into credit strategies, infrastructure, and essential service assets. Until pricing adjusts to reflect these higher capital costs, most investors are staying patient—waiting for equity risk to actually pay off.
5. The Insurance Crisis Is Making Properties Uninvestable
Property insurance costs have skyrocketed—especially in states like Florida, Texas, and California—making deals uninsurable or too expensive to carry. Some insurance companies are even pulling out of high-risk markets entirely.
6. Rent Growth Is Slowing—Or Even Declining
The post-pandemic rental boom has subsided, with many cities experiencing flat or declining rents. In January 2025, the national average rent decreased by 0.1% year-over-year to $1,599, marking a stabilization in rental prices. Investors who purchased properties at peak prices in 2021-2022 are now facing challenges as their projected returns are not materializing. Even if rental pricing power returns, it may outpace the Consumer Price Index (CPI) at an unsustainable rate, potentially pricing out future renters and creating a demand ceiling that stifles long-term growth. rent.com
7. The Economy Is Too Uncertain for Big Moves
No one knows if the Fed will cut rates in late 2024 or hold steady into 2025, and that uncertainty is freezing investor activity. But here’s the reality—rock-bottom 3% interest rates were never sustainable. The ultra-low-rate environment of the past decade wasn’t normal; it was a byproduct of emergency economic stimulus that created asset bubbles across real estate, stocks, and venture capital. Healthy economies don’t operate on near-zero interest rates. Instead, investors should start adjusting to a world where 4-6% borrowing costs are the long-term baseline—because that’s where rates sat for most of modern history before the 2008 crisis. Real estate strategies need to be built around realistic cost of capital expectations, not the artificial debt-fueled boom of the last. Reuters
8. The Office Real Estate Collapse Is a Warning Sign
The office sector is experiencing significant distress, primarily due to the widespread adoption of remote work and hybrid models following the COVID-19 pandemic. This shift has led to increased vacancy rates and declining property values. In response, lenders are tightening credit across the board, becoming more cautious even in traditionally stable asset classes like multifamily and industrial real estate. This conservative approach stems from concerns about rising delinquency rates and the overall instability within the commercial real estate market.
9. Development Costs Are Still Too High
Construction materials and labor costs remain elevated, making ground-up development financially impossible in most markets. The ongoing trade war between the U.S. and China, along with supply chain disruptions, continues to drive up prices for essential building materials like steel, lumber, and concrete. Prefab and modular construction offer solutions, but financing remains a major hurdle.
10. Institutional Buyers Are on Pause—And That Says Everything
The biggest players—REITs, pension funds, and private equity firms—have slowed acquisitions significantly, waiting for a better buying environment. They’re instead choosing safer, higher-yielding credit investments over real estate equity, where the risk no longer justifies the return. If big money is sitting this one out, smaller investors should take note.
11. Presidential Remarks Stir Economic Uncertainty
President Donald Trump’s recent comments have added to market volatility. In a Fox News interview, he refused to rule out the possibility of a recession, stating that the U.S. is in a “period of transition” due to his tariff policies. This ambiguity has contributed to significant market declines, with the Dow Jones falling over 2% and the Nasdaq dropping 4% on Monday. businessinsider.com
12. Recession: A Double-Edged Sword for Investors
While a recession poses challenges, it can also present unique opportunities for astute investors. Economic downturns often lead to distressed asset sales, lower property valuations, and motivated sellers, creating a more favorable environment for acquisitions. Historically, those prepared to act during recessions have secured high-quality assets at discounted prices, positioning themselves for substantial gains during subsequent recoveries. Therefore, maintaining liquidity and readiness to capitalize on emerging opportunities is crucial.
So, When Do Investors Jump Back In?
I know—I sound like a preacher on a Sunday morning, or maybe like the boy crying wolf for the hundredth time. But the reality is, this market isn’t ready yet. I’m not here to chase overpriced deals just because everyone else is restless. I’m waiting—like a shark circling the water, knowing the right moment is coming. When we finally see forced selling, real price discovery, and the Fed making a clear move, that’s when the feeding frenzy starts. Until then, patience beats desperation—and keeps you from losing to the sharks.
Is this the calm before the storm? Let me know what you think. – AM
Leave a Reply